Q: I want to put wood flooring in my walk-out basement. Since it is below grade, I understand that I need to use an engineered wood floor.
Can you tell me if engineered wood flooring is made with high volatile organic compounds (VOCs) such as formaldehyde, benzene, xylene, etc? Does the GLUE used to hold together the various layers have these volatile organic compounds?
Some manufacturers (like Schon) have a layer of MDF between the plywood layers. Is MDF considered a "pressed wood" therefore making it a product with high volatile organic compounds?
Typically does the finish on a solid wood floor or an engineered wood floor contain VOCs? Again, I want to ensure that the flooring won't make me sick. I understand that I can have my installer use a water-based adhesive (low VOC adhesive) to hold the floor down. I just need to make sure that the components used in the actual flooring don't contain high levels of volatile organic compounds.
Please respond as soon as possible so I can make an informed decision on my flooring.
Thank you.
Kathryn
A: VOC content in adhesives is heavily based on manufacturer, as each engineered floor uses a different adhesive. Your best bet to find a floor which is easier for you when it comes to VOC content is to research the emission ratings of the floors you are interested in. Look for E0 or E1 as these are the two lowest ratings. You may have to contact manufacturers directly to get this information as it can be difficult to find at times.
However, I do have a bit of information that will help make this much easier. Look into a 5/16” solid hardwood. Due to the design of these floors, they are stable enough to be installed over concrete and below grade. With the 5/16” solid you will only encounter the glue used to adhere the floor to your subfloor and none in the product. Westhollow carries a great 5/16” collection.
Follow-up: Kathryn and I have spoken a bit more on her project. Looking into both 5/16" solid and laminate as possible choices for her floor. Here's a follow-up email I received:
Thank you for referring me to the Westhollow products. I did look at the 5/16" solids and they are beautiful. And, there is a store in Melbourne, FL so I can look at the actual products.
** I do have a question about the Westhollow laminates. Do these have a E0 or E1 rating? I read the descriptions and noticed that they were made with a high density fiberboard (wood shavings and resins). My guess is that these would probably off-gas. Do you have any information? **
From a website called, GreenGuard.com, I got the names of two manufacturers who are certified to have low/zero emission laminates. They are DuPont and Wilsonart. I also learned that EcoTimber produces a low emission engineered wood floor.
Thanks again and I look forward to your response.
A: As I recall off hand all Westhollow products are E0 or E1 rated, but I'll get in touch with Ryan W., who is our product guru here just to make sure. Wilsonart has always made great products, but to get the really good laminate they make you do shell out a few extra bucks.
One thing to keep in mind with Laminate is to have a good underlayment to remove the hollow or "clicky" noise these floors produce when they are walked over. Although there is some resin used to create the high-density fiberboards, they are super durable floors. We recently did some Tabar testing on several floors for Westhollow as we wanted to compare solid and engineered hardwoods against bamboo and laminate floors to get some ideas of where each floor will perform.
No surprises showed laminate to be the top dog when it comes to abrasion, durability, dent resistance and even moisture resistance. However, the engineered hardwoods performed very well, getting rather close to laminate in each test.
The one benefit to the 5/16" solid I suggested is they perform well like an engineered will for durability, but they are a solid hardwood so they add great value to your home. However, if durability is your large concern, laminate and engineered woods will be your better bet. I'll shoot a quick email over to Ryan and get back to you with the emission ratings for the Westhollow products. Have a good one!
As a bit of follow-up Ryan W. let me know that all of Westhollow's newer laminate collections were tested to be E1 on the emission standards, perfect for folks with a chemical sensitivity. This includes the Heritage Standard, Silencer American Traditions and Silencer Exotic Antiquities.